Senator Schiff accuses CFTC chair of misleading Senate on prediction‑market rules
Sen. Adam Schiff says CFTC Chair Michael Selig promised to defer to courts on sports‑event contracts but urged firms to ignore court guidance, sparking a heated Senate hearing.
Key takeaways
- Sen. Adam Schiff alleged that CFTC Chair Michael Selig misled senators about the agency’s stance on sports‑event prediction contracts.
- During a Nov. 17 Senate Agriculture Committee hearing, nominees Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland said they would follow a future Supreme Court ruling on the issue.
- The hearing also highlighted CFTC staffing cuts of 25% and a 167% rise in listed contracts since 2024.
At a Senate Agriculture Committee hearing on Nov. 17, Democratic Senator Adam Schiff accused Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) Chair Michael Selig of “blatantly deceiving” the panel about the agency’s approach to prediction‑market contracts that resemble sports bets. Schiff said Selig had previously pledged to let the courts decide the legality of such contracts, yet later directed firms to ignore court opinions, creating a conflict that the Senate is now probing.
Chair’s alleged reversal on court guidance
According to the hearing record, Schiff recalled asking Selig at his own confirmation hearing whether a contract on a football game qualified as sports betting. Selig responded that he would be a “blank slate” and would defer to judicial rulings. Schiff claimed the chair later filed briefs urging courts to adopt the CFTC’s position and told exchanges to disregard state gambling laws, contradicting his earlier promise.
Nominees’ cautious stance on the legal question
Republican nominee Nathan Anonick and Democrat nominee Matthew Rowland, both nominated by former President Donald Trump, declined to label a prediction‑market contract on the Indianapolis Colts‑Houston Texans game as a bet. Anonick described the issue as “complex” and said federal courts have issued conflicting decisions, while pledging to “fully support” the CFTC if the Supreme Court ultimately rules on the matter. Rowland echoed the uncertainty, noting the litigation is “hard to comment on” but expressed sympathy for state and tribal concerns.
Broader concerns: staffing, market growth and political ties
The hearing also turned to the CFTC’s capacity, with Sen. Michael Bennet noting a 167% increase in listed contracts since 2024 alongside a 25% reduction in agency staff. Both nominees said restoring staffing levels and enforcement resources would be a priority. Additionally, Senators raised the appearance of political influence, referencing that President Donald Trump’s son had advised prediction‑market platforms Kalshi and Polymarket. Rowland asserted that the law should be enforced “without fear or favor.”
What to watch next
The committee has not yet voted on the two nominees, leaving the record open for two business days. Observers will monitor whether the Senate confirms Anonick and Rowland, how the CFTC proceeds with its November 5 interpretation that urged exchanges to drop state geoblocks, and when—if at all—the Supreme Court takes up the sports‑bet classification dispute.
Frequently asked questions
What is the legal dispute over prediction‑market contracts?
The question is whether contracts that pay out based on the outcome of a sporting event are considered illegal sports bets or permissible commodity contracts, a matter that courts have ruled on inconsistently.
Why does the CFTC’s stance matter for crypto derivatives?
Many crypto‑based platforms, such as Kalshi and Polymarket, offer event‑based contracts that fall under the CFTC’s jurisdiction; the agency’s interpretation affects how these platforms can operate in the United States.
Sources
- Bitcoin.com News: Schiff Says CFTC Chair ‘Blatantly Deceived’ Him on Prediction Markets
- Tokenpost: Schiff Accuses CFTC Chairman Selig of Breaking Prediction-Market Pledge
Not financial advice. Crypto assets are volatile and you can lose money. Read our Financial Risk Disclosure.
Crypto news checked against two or more sources, prices and a daily market brief.
- Take‑Two Interactive shares jump 6‑7% as GTA 6 earns near‑perfect reviews
- Hyperliquid Policy Center urges FCA to treat public blockchains as neutral infrastructure
- AI-driven attacks threaten crypto security in 2027, says Anchorage co‑founder